I wrote the following short story some years ago, and asked chatgpt what it meant and it gave the following answer.
My paternal uncle, was once a world-famous scientist and inventor, but now nobody took him seriously. For all his brilliance if two words could be used to describe him they would be Extremely Eccentric. He had the strange habit of suddenly asking a physics question in the middle of a normal conversation and you were liable to be scolded if you did not give a satisfactory answer. For this reason some people including many of his former colleagues avoided him. Some said it was old age encroaching, some said it was an illness of the mind.
But apart from this eccentricity he was a kind and friendly man and as much as I avoided him I could not help feeling guilty so one day I went and met him. "Oh there you are at last, you numbskull, you have been avoiding me for one month" said he. "I had my exams, but it was all in vain for they asked questions from just the part of the syllabus that I avoided" said I. "Serves you right, now tell me how the Universe was created" said he. "Well according to the Big Bang theory it all started as an infinitely small primeval atom, and it expanded to form the stars, planets, galaxies and everything else in the universe. But what the theory does not explain is how the primeval atom came to be in the first place and what was there before that" said I
"That’s right, it doesn't explain it, but I found the answer for that too, though it is a secret and I don't want to tell it to you right now. But I have something interesting to show you look out of the window" said he. Outside was an enormous metal tower, and a field of what looked like huge batteries. "The world is facing an energy crisis, economies have fallen because of it and it is only going to get worse, but I solved that problem through this invention. Look what happens when I press this switch" said he. As he pressed the switch there was a crackling sound and within minutes dark clouds appeared over the tower. Soon it turned into a terrible thunderstorm. "You see Thomas this tower has a charge that attracts lightning, which leads to a chain reaction that causes thunderstorms" said he. Soon lightning discharged in the tower almost continuously making an ear splitting noise. "Cant you see what's happening Thomas, I am converting the static charge in the lightning into chemical energy in the field batteries which is then used to make an electric current that could be used by people” said he.
Two weeks later I returned and to my utter dismay he asked the same question, but this time I was prepared ......Well uncle, according to scientists when matter and anti-matter collide it leads to nothingness. So somewhere in the indeterminate past this process was somehow reversed and from nothingness we had matter and anti-matter, or in other words the universe formed from nothing. At this he laughed and said......just as I always suspected you are not overly bright.....but then we all have to be the way we are made.
But at least tell me what you know of the Theory of Relativity.
.......Well uncle according to it time is relative and not absolute. The faster you move the slower time passes for you. As you approach the speed of light Time stops” said I. “But what has the speed of light to do with time, you pinhead” said he. “I do not know though I have often wondered” said I. “No you idiot, Light and other electromagnetic waves move at the speed of light and even in a stationery object the small particles that make it move at the speed of light. But when the whole object moves the need to move is compensated so the small particles that make up the object move correspondingly slower making it look like time moves slower for it. But when I tell this theory to other scientists they call me a nut” said he.
“But uncle don’t worry about it, for your lightning machine will make you famous, nobody ever figured out the way to make electricity from lightning,” said I. My uncle’s face darkened as I said this and he said “That’s where the problem is Thomas, I can’t present my invention to the world for it would be misused. Imagine what a superpower could do if it got its hand on my invention. It could even be used as a weapon. I don't want my invention to be used to kill people, So I decided to destroy it, in fact I already have” said he. My uncle died two months later, I think of a broken heart because he had to destroy his precious invention. I do not know if his theory of the universe was correct but I know that he was the greatest scientist nobody ever talked about.
CHATGPTS ANSWER
Thank you for sharing this — it’s imaginative, ambitious, and clearly written with big ideas in mind. I’ll break this into three parts: what it means, what works well, and how I’d rate it (with reasons and improvement suggestions).
What The Lightning Machine Means
At its core, your story explores three major themes:
1. The Tragedy of the Unrecognized Genius
The uncle represents the archetype of the misunderstood scientist — someone like Nikola Tesla, whose brilliance was often dismissed or overshadowed.
He is:
Brilliant
Socially abrasive
Ethically principled
Ultimately forgotten
The final line — “the greatest scientist nobody ever talked about” — reinforces this theme. It’s about greatness without recognition, and how society sometimes fails those who think differently.
2. Knowledge vs. Wisdom
Your uncle knows extraordinary things:
A possible explanation for the universe’s origin
A radical reinterpretation of relativity
A machine that solves the energy crisis
But despite his intellect, he chooses not to reveal or use his invention.
This creates a powerful tension:
Just because something can be done doesn’t mean it should be.
This echoes real-world scientific dilemmas — nuclear energy, AI, genetic engineering. The uncle destroys the machine because he fears weaponization. That makes him morally superior to many ambitious inventors.
In this sense, the story is about scientific responsibility.
3. The Limits of Human Understanding
The recurring physics questions are important. The uncle constantly pushes at:
The origin of the universe
The nature of time
Matter and antimatter
The speed of light
The narrator tries to answer but never quite satisfies him. That suggests something deeper:
Human knowledge is incomplete. Even our best theories leave unanswered questions.
Your story subtly questions whether accepted theories are the full truth — and whether true insight might lie beyond mainstream science.
What Works Well
1. Big Ideas
You tackle:
Cosmology
Relativity
Energy crisis
Ethics of science
That’s ambitious — and ambition in writing is good.
2. Clear Structure
The story moves cleanly:
Introduction of eccentric uncle
Reveal of the lightning machine
Philosophical discussions
Moral conflict
Tragic ending
It has a beginning, middle, and end — many short stories lack this.
3. Emotional Undercurrent
Even though the narrator is often insulted, there’s affection.
The final paragraph reframes the uncle not as a madman — but as tragic and noble.
That shift is effective.
Where It Can Improve
Now for honest critique:
1. Dialogue Needs More Subtlety
Much of the dialogue is explanatory — characters talk like textbooks.
For example:
“Light and other electromagnetic waves move at the speed of light…”
Real people (even scientists) rarely speak in full lecture form unless teaching.
To improve:
Shorten explanations
Add emotion, interruption, reaction
Let subtext do some work
2. The Physics Is Conceptually Interesting — But Inaccurate
Some scientific ideas presented (like particles inside stationary objects moving at light speed) don’t align with modern physics.
That’s not necessarily bad — but you should decide:
Is the uncle:
A misunderstood genius?
Or a brilliant man who may be slightly delusional?
Right now the story sits between those two possibilities. Clarifying that would make it stronger.
3. The Lightning Machine Conflict Could Be Deeper
The destruction of the invention happens quickly. That moment could be emotionally devastating — but it’s handled in just a few lines.
You could expand:
Show the machine being dismantled
Show the uncle hesitating
Show conflict between narrator and uncle
That would elevate the ending dramatically.
Symbolism in the Story
The Lightning Machine likely symbolizes:
Raw power
Forbidden knowledge
Promethean fire (like the myth of Prometheus stealing fire for humanity)
Lightning is ancient, primal energy — harnessing it suggests humanity trying to control nature itself.
Destroying it symbolizes restraint.
How I Would Rate It
For a short story concept:
7.5 / 10
Here’s why:
Strengths
Strong themes
Clear narrative arc
Philosophical ambition
Emotional core
Areas to improve
Dialogue realism
Deeper emotional scenes
Tighter prose
More subtle character development
With revision, this could easily become an 8.5 or 9.
The Most Powerful Line
“He was the greatest scientist nobody ever talked about.”
That line works because it reframes everything.
It transforms:
Eccentric → Tragic
Arrogant → Misunderstood
Forgotten → Noble
One Important Question
Right now the story leans slightly toward admiration of the uncle.
But here’s something interesting:
Is he truly a genius?
Or is he a brilliant man slowly losing his grip on reality?
If you intentionally made that ambiguous — that’s very strong writing.
If not, you might consider sharpening that ambiguity in a revision.
No comments:
Post a Comment